Air fryer Valentine’s Day Homemade Strawberry Pop Tarts

These air fryer homemade strawberry pop tarts are unbelievably easy to make with pre-made pie crusts, strawberry preserves, and a delicious glaze. Don’t forget the sprinkles on top!

Ok, I’ve done it. I’ve finally jumped on the air fryer bandwagon, and I couldn’t be more excited. For at least the past 3 years, I’ve been hearing about how great air fryers are and how amazing the food turns out.

So I bought this air fryer and had to pick something to make in it on its “maiden voyage.” Hmmmm, what to make?

I know! Valentine’s Day is just around the corner, so how about something delicious, easy – and very kid-oriented? Something like…

today’s homemade pop tart recipe!

Air Fryer Strawberry Homemade Pop Tarts

These Air Fryer Homemade Strawberry Pop Tarts are ultra-easy to make since they use refrigerated pie crust and strawberry jam. Don’t they make the ultra kid food?

And they take me back to my childhood too!

As a child in the 80’s and 90’s, pop tarts were THE thing. I remember the commercials for them even to this day. But funny, I haven’t had one in many years…until now!

Grab your air fryer – it’s time to whip up some heart-shaped air fryer strawberry pop tarts. 😘

More Valentine’s Day fun! Grab these free Valentine’s Bingo printables and other activities that will have kids laughing and having a great time! Click the image below.

They air fry to golden perfection nearly as fast as it takes to open a box of Pop Tarts. The final touch is to drizzle them in a very simple, classic icing, and – of course – sprinkles!

Check out another Valentine’s Day (or any day) fun with M&M Valentine’s Day Hot Cocoa Bombs!

The Argument For Making Your Own

Here’s the thing…I know how busy moms are. I also know the desire to give your kids delicious food and sweet treats but the struggle to find the time to make them all is real.

So many moms turn to buying pre-made items to save time.

I get it – no judgement here. ❤️️

In my own personal struggle, I’ve discovered that there are things that are worth buying and things worth spending time to make.

For me, it comes down to the number and types of ingredients in the pre-made versions and the amount of time it takes to make them – and since these homemade pop tarts take mere minutes to make, they’re definitely worth making!

Commercial Pop Tarts have multiple types of added sugar, additives and preservatives that I’m not a fan of.

If you’re like me and want simple foods that don’t take a lot of time, you’ll be happy to know that these air fryer pop tarts use simple ingredients.

Don’t they look amazing?

Air Fryer Strawberry Pop Tarts Ingredients

• 15 oz Pie crusts (equivalent to 2 crusts)
• 4 ounces strawberry preserves total (reserve 1 oz for the frosting) 
• 1 cup powdered sugar
• 1 egg, whisked 
• 4 tablespoons Valentine’s Day sprinkles
• 1 heart cookie cutter 

How to Make Air Fryer Pop Tarts

Follow these directions to make your own mouthwatering pop tarts!

Step 1

Lay your pie crust out flat on a lightly floured surface. With your cookie cutter, cut out as many heart-shaped hearts as you can with the amount of pie crust you have.

Step 2

On one of the heart-shaped crust, take 1 tablespoon of your jelly preserves, and place it in the middle. Spread it out evenly on the heart shape. Make sure to leave room around the edges.

Step 3

Taking your finger, dip it in the egg wash, and evenly spread the egg wash around the edges surrounding the jelly.

Step 4

Place another heart-shaped pie crust on top of the other heart with the jelly on it. Using a fork, press down the edges, creating a seal. 

Step 5

Using a kitchen brush, dip it in the egg wash and top the rest of your heart shape with the egg wash.

Step 6

Using a fork, or toothpick, poke about 6 to 8 holes in the top of your top layer of pastry.

Want fun seasonal activities you can use for Valentine’s Day at home or school parties? Grab this free packet!

Step 7

Depending on the size of your air fryer, place as many pastry hearts in your air fryer that will fit without interfering with the shape of the pastry.

Step 8

Cook your pop tart at 370° for 7 minutes. Once the timer is done, open your air fryer, and flip your pop tarts. Continue to cook at 370° for an additional 3 to 4 minutes, or until it is reached a soft brown color.

Step 9

Remove from the air fryer, and transfer to a cooling rack.

Step 10

While your pastries are cooling, mix together your powdered sugar and jelly preserve. Mix, and whisk together. You can choose to add more powdered sugar if you like your frosting thicker. 

Step 11

Drizzle your frosting over your pop tart and add your sprinkles while your frosting is still wet.

Step 12

Allow them to cool and the frosting to harden, and then enjoy!

Air Fryer Strawberry Pop Tarts FAQs

Here are some common questions about making homemade strawberry pop tarts in the air fryer and their answers.

Can You Make Homemade Pop Tarts in the Oven?

I haven’t done this myself, but based on a similar recipe I make in the oven, I’d recommend baking them at 400 degrees F for 10-20 minutes. Or until the crusts are golden brown!

How Do You Store Homemade Strawberry Pop Tarts?

Keep them fresh by storing them in an airtight container in the fridge.

How Long Do Homemade Pop Tarts Last?

These air fryer pop tarts will last in the fridge for about a week, although they won’t last that long!

Can I Freeze These Air Fryer Pop Tarts?

If you want to freeze them, pop tightly sealed leftover pop tarts in the freezer for up to 3 months.

Then, when you want them, reheat them in the air fryer for 6-8 minutes on 370 degrees or until warm.

What is Pop Tart Crust Made of?

This recipe uses pre-made refrigerated pie crusts as the crust. 

Homemade Strawberry Pop Tarts Variation Ideas

For this recipe, I used strawberry jam because it just seemed to fit (and we love strawberries).

If you want to add some variation to this homemade pop tart recipe, try:

• different flavors of jam – raspberry, blackberry, peach, blueberry, grape, etc.
• different shapes – circles, squares or rectangles, etc.

No matter how you choose to change it, the directions stay the same!

Tips

When using an air fryer, it’s important not to have food items touching each other, as the air needs to be able to circulate.

If you can’t fit everything into your air fryer in a way that they won’t touch each other, simply air fry the pastries in batches instead!

More Valentine’s Day fun! Grab these free Valentine’s Bingo printables and other activities that will have kids laughing and having a great time! Click the image below.

Tender, flakey crust cooked golden brown and filled with delicious jam them covered with icing and sprinkles? Yummmm…a perfect handmade version of a childhood classic!

Enjoy these homemade strawberry pop tarts!

Pin for Later!