Homemade Eggnog Recipe (Creamy & Non-Alcoholic)

A glass of thick, creamy homemade eggnog that just SCREAMS Christmas! But after walking past carton after carton of store-bought eggnog at the grocery store (and reading those ingredient lists), I decided it was time to make my own. And OH MY GOODNESS, am I glad I did!

homemade eggnog in a glass

This homemade eggnog recipe is rich, velvety smooth, perfectly spiced, and made with simple ingredients you probably already have in your kitchen. It’s an old-fashioned holiday favorite with a family-friendly twist: no alcohol and no raw eggs in the finished drink!

And here’s the best part: making eggnog from scratch is SO much easier than you might think.

The secret is heating the egg mixture slowly and paying attention to the temperature. I’ll walk you through exactly how to get that dreamy, creamy texture without accidentally making scrambled eggs.

Because nobody wants scrambled eggnog for Christmas. 😂

My family has some VERY dedicated eggnog drinkers, and after making this recipe again and again, I can confidently say that homemade is the way to go.

Whether you’re hosting Christmas dinner, planning a holiday party, or simply curling up beside the Christmas tree with a cozy drink, this easy non-alcoholic eggnog is about to become a holiday favorite!

Why You’ll LOVE This Homemade Eggnog Recipe

I’ve tried plenty of holiday drinks, but there’s something special about a good, old-fashioned eggnog.

And this recipe has several things going for it!

  • Incredibly creamy: Whole milk, heavy cream, and eggs create that thick, velvety texture eggnog lovers crave.
  • Made with simple ingredients: No complicated ingredients or specialty equipment required.
  • Non-alcoholic and family-friendly: Everyone can enjoy a glass, including the kids.
  • Uses cooked eggs: The egg mixture is heated to 160°F instead of being served raw.
  • Made with whole eggs: No separating yolks and whites or figuring out what to do with leftover egg whites.
  • Easy to customize: Adjust the sweetness, cinnamon, and nutmeg to suit your family’s tastes.
  • Perfect for making ahead: Eggnog tastes even better after a few hours in the refrigerator.
  • Great for holiday entertaining: One batch makes approximately 12 servings.

Plus, homemade eggnog has that wonderful, freshly made flavor you just can’t beat.

If you love making holiday favorites from scratch, be sure to try my Homemade Hot Chocolate and Peppermint Bark recipes, too!

What Is Eggnog?

Eggnog is a traditional holiday drink made with eggs, milk or cream, sugar, and warm spices such as nutmeg and cinnamon.

It’s known for its rich, custard-like flavor and thick, creamy consistency.

Some traditional eggnog recipes use raw eggs, while others cook the egg mixture. Eggnog can also contain alcohol, but it certainly doesn’t have to!

This particular recipe is a cooked, non-alcoholic eggnog, making it a wonderful option for families and holiday gatherings where you want everyone to enjoy the same festive drink.

And if you’ve never tried homemade eggnog before, you’re in for a treat!

homemade eggnog from above

Homemade Eggnog Ingredients

You don’t need a long list of fancy ingredients to make delicious eggnog from scratch.

In fact, you probably have most of these sitting in your kitchen right now.

NOTE: for more recipe details, check out the handy printable recipe card at the bottom of the post!

Here’s what you’ll need and why each ingredient matters.

Eggs

You’ll need 12 whole eggs.

Yes, TWELVE!

The eggs give homemade eggnog its signature richness and help thicken the mixture as it cooks.

I use whole eggs instead of separating the yolks and whites, which makes preparation much easier.

The important thing is to heat them gently. Eggs can scramble if the mixture gets too hot too quickly.

And trust me, that’s one holiday surprise you DON’T want.

Whole Milk

The recipe uses 4 cups of whole milk.

Whole milk gives the eggnog its creamy consistency without making it excessively heavy.

You can adjust the thickness with a little extra milk after the eggnog has chilled.

Heavy Whipping Cream

You’ll need 1 cup of heavy whipping cream.

This is what gives the finished drink that wonderfully rich, luxurious texture.

The cream is stirred in after the cooked egg mixture reaches 160°F and is removed from the heat.

Sugar

The recipe calls for 1¼ cups of sugar.

Eggnog is supposed to be a sweet holiday treat, but you can adjust the sweetness to your preferences.

If you want to experiment with a sugar substitute, I’ve also used the idea of replacing sugar with Lakanto Monk Fruit.

Choose a product labeled as a 1:1 sugar replacement and follow its instructions. Keep in mind that alternative sweeteners may change the flavor or texture slightly.

Cinnamon and Nutmeg

You’ll need:

  • 1 teaspoon ground cinnamon
  • 1 teaspoon ground nutmeg

These warm spices are what make homemade eggnog taste like Christmas in a glass!

I especially love using freshly ground nutmeg.

If you’ve never tried it, consider buying whole fresh nutmeg and grinding it yourself.

The aroma alone is AMAZING.

You can also experiment with freshly ground cinnamon for even more flavor.

And if you love nutmeg as much as I do, don’t forget to sprinkle a little extra on top before serving.

Vanilla Extract

You’ll need 2 teaspoons of vanilla extract.

Vanilla brings everything together and adds a lovely warmth to the finished drink.

Salt

Just a pinch of salt is enough.

It might seem insignificant, but it helps balance the sweetness and brings out the other flavors.

Don’t skip it!

Note: The exact measurements and printable instructions are included in the recipe card at the bottom of the post.

Two glasses of decadent, creamy non-alcoholic eggnog with cinnamon sticks and Christmas decorations

Alcohol

Alcohol acts as a preservative and a sterilizer so that it kills any salmonella (just in case you love the traditional version and are freaked out to learn it contains raw eggs).

I strongly prefer this non-alcoholic eggnog recipe to the traditional stuff for several reasons:

  • The thought of drinking raw eggs – I personally can’t stomach it. I Just. Can’t.
  • Plus, we are non-alcohol drinkers at my house.
  • And, finally, I want my kids to be able to partake but don’t want to give them a raw egg-filled, boozy drink.

If you love the rich, creamy taste of classic eggnog, but don’t like the idea of using raw eggs, this non-alcoholic eggnog recipe is for you!

non-alcoholic eggnog recipe in a glass with cinnamon sticks

How to Make Homemade Eggnog (Step-by-Step)

Ready to make the BEST creamy homemade eggnog?

Grab a saucepan, a whisk, and a food thermometer.

The process is simple, but this is one recipe where patience REALLY pays off.

Step 1: Whisk the eggs and sugar

In a medium mixing bowl, combine the 12 eggs and 1¼ cups of sugar.

Whisk until everything is thoroughly combined.

You don’t need to whip the mixture until it’s fluffy. Just make sure the eggs and sugar are well incorporated.

Step 2: Add the milk and spices

Transfer the egg-and-sugar mixture to a saucepan.

Stir in the whole milk, ground cinnamon, and ground nutmeg.

Mix until the ingredients are combined.

Step 3: Slowly cook the eggnog

Place the saucepan over medium-low heat.

Heat the mixture gently, stirring regularly with a whisk and increasing to continuous stirring as it becomes hot.

This is the step where you’ll want to pay attention!

As the mixture warms, the eggs begin to thicken the liquid.

If the heat is too high or the mixture sits still against the hot bottom of the pan, the eggs can begin to scramble.

And nobody wants little egg chunks floating around in their Christmas drink.

The goal is slow, gentle heating—not boiling.

Use a food thermometer to monitor the temperature.

Continue heating until the mixture reaches 160°F.

Step 4: Add the cream, vanilla, and salt

Once the egg mixture reaches 160°F, remove the saucepan from the heat.

Slowly whisk in:

  • 1 cup heavy whipping cream
  • 2 teaspoons vanilla extract
  • A pinch of salt

Stir until everything is thoroughly combined.

At this point, your kitchen should smell absolutely WONDERFUL!

Step 5: Taste and adjust

Allow the eggnog to cool slightly, then taste a small amount once it’s cool enough to sample safely.

Want a little more cinnamon?

Go for it!

Prefer a stronger nutmeg flavor?

Add a little extra.

This is YOUR homemade eggnog, so make it exactly how you like it.

Step 6: Cool and refrigerate

Cool the eggnog promptly, using an ice bath or dividing it into smaller, shallow containers if needed.

Transfer it to a covered, food-safe container and refrigerate within two hours of cooking.

Chill for at least several hours, preferably about 5–6 hours or overnight.

The mixture will continue to thicken as it gets cold, and the flavors will have time to blend together.

Trust me, it’s worth the wait!

Step 7: Serve and enjoy!

Give your chilled eggnog a good stir before serving.

Pour it into glasses or mugs and top with freshly grated nutmeg, cinnamon, or a dollop of irresistible whipped cream.

Then sit back, relax, and enjoy your homemade holiday masterpiece.

How to Make Perfectly Smooth Eggnog Without Scrambling the Eggs

Okay, friends.

We need to talk about the ONE thing that can make or break homemade eggnog.

The texture!

I’ve had readers tell me that they stirred constantly but still ended up with lumpy eggnog.

Others have told me they stirred so much that it took FOREVER for the mixture to heat up.

And I completely understand the frustration.

The good news?

I’ve made this recipe many times, and I’ve learned a few tricks that make a HUGE difference.

1. Keep the heat low

This is the biggest secret to creamy homemade eggnog.

Use medium-low heat, or lower if your stove runs hot.

Heating the mixture too quickly can cause the eggs to cook unevenly and form little lumps.

Slow and steady wins this race!

2. Use a whisk instead of a spoon

I prefer stirring my eggnog with a whisk.

But here’s the important part: I don’t vigorously beat the mixture.

I simply use the whisk to stir, just as I would with a spoon.

The whisk helps keep everything moving and breaks up small bits before they become noticeable lumps.

3. Adjust your stirring as the eggnog heats

Here’s the method that’s worked well for me.

When I first put the cold mixture into the saucepan, I give it a little time to begin warming.

After about 3–5 minutes, once I can feel the pan getting warm, I start stirring regularly.

Early on, I may take a very brief pause between stirs.

As the eggnog gets hotter, those pauses become shorter.

And once the mixture is really warming up, I stir continuously.

IMPORTANT: A brief pause is NOT the same thing as walking away to switch the laundry!

This is not a recipe you want to leave unattended.

If your pan heats quickly, begin stirring immediately and keep the mixture moving throughout cooking.

4. Use a thermometer

Don’t guess whether your eggnog is ready.

Use a reliable food thermometer and make sure the cooked egg mixture reaches 160°F.

The eggnog should thicken slightly, but it shouldn’t boil.

5. Don’t rush the process

I know it’s tempting to turn up the heat when you’re tired of stirring.

DON’T DO IT!

Rushing is one of the easiest ways to end up with curdled or scrambled eggnog.

Give the mixture the time it needs.

Your patience will be rewarded with wonderfully creamy eggnog.

non-alcoholic eggnog recipe in a glass with cinnamon sticks

Why Is My Homemade Eggnog Lumpy?

If your eggnog develops lumps, don’t panic!

Small lumps usually mean that some of the eggs cooked faster than the rest of the mixture.

Here are a few ways to troubleshoot.

If your eggnog has small lumps

Try pouring the mixture through a fine-mesh strainer to remove the cooked egg pieces.

You can also whisk the mixture gently to see whether any small lumps will break apart.

An immersion blender may help smooth the texture, although it won’t completely reverse eggs that have scrambled.

Important: If the mixture hasn’t yet reached 160°F, continue heating it carefully until it does. Straining or blending doesn’t replace proper cooking.

If your eggnog is too thick

This is an easy fix!

Simply stir in additional whole milk, about ¼ cup at a time, until you reach your preferred consistency.

I recommend doing this after the eggnog has chilled because it naturally thickens as it cools.

If your eggnog separates

Homemade eggnog can separate a little during refrigeration.

That’s normal!

Give it a good whisk before serving.

You can also use an immersion blender for a quick mix if needed.

If the eggnog has an unusual odor, shows signs of spoilage, or has been stored improperly, discard it rather than trying to fix it.

Can I use an automatic pot stirrer?

I’ve had readers ask about automatic stirrers because standing at the stove for an extended period isn’t everyone’s idea of holiday fun.

I haven’t personally tested these products, but two options I’ve looked into are the StirMATE automatic pot stirrer and the LAMPCOOK automatic pot stirrer and pot combo.

If you decide to use one, make sure it’s compatible with your cookware and follow the manufacturer’s directions.

You’ll still need to monitor the eggnog’s temperature and check that the mixture is heating evenly.

Homemade Eggnog Recipe Variations and Substitutions

One of the things I love about making eggnog from scratch is that you can adjust it to suit your family’s preferences.

Here are a few ideas!

Make it extra creamy

If you love thick, rich eggnog, prepare the recipe as written and allow it to chill thoroughly.

The eggs will help the mixture thicken as it cools.

For a thinner consistency, add a little more whole milk before serving.

Make it a little less sweet

You can experiment with reducing the sugar slightly or using a 1:1 sugar substitute.

Just remember that changing the sugar can affect both the sweetness and the overall texture.

Add more holiday spices

Love cinnamon?

Add a little extra!

Can’t get enough nutmeg?

Sprinkle some freshly grated nutmeg on top.

You could also experiment with a tiny pinch of cloves or allspice for a different holiday flavor.

Start small. Those spices can become overpowering VERY quickly.

Make an adults-only version

This recipe is delicious exactly as written, and my family enjoys it without alcohol.

However, adults who prefer spiked eggnog can add brandy, rum, bourbon, or whiskey to their individual servings, to taste.

Keep alcoholic servings clearly separate from the family-friendly batch.

And remember: alcohol does not reliably make raw eggs safe. The eggs still need to be properly cooked.

non-alcoholic eggnog recipe in a glass

How to Serve Homemade Eggnog

There are SO many delicious ways to enjoy homemade eggnog during the holidays.

Of course, my favorite is the classic approach: pour it into a glass, add a little freshly grated nutmeg, and enjoy!

But here are a few more ideas.

Add a festive topping

Try topping your eggnog with:

  • Homemade whipped cream
  • Freshly grated nutmeg
  • Ground cinnamon
  • A cinnamon stick
  • A light dusting of cocoa powder

It’s an easy way to make an ordinary glass of eggnog feel like a special Christmas treat.

Serve it with Christmas cookies and desserts

Eggnog is wonderfully rich, so it pairs nicely with small holiday desserts.

Try serving it alongside my Mini Cheesecake Bites or Fruitcake Cookies.

YUM!

Make eggnog hot chocolate

Have a little leftover eggnog?

Turn it into a cozy mug of eggnog hot chocolate!

It’s a delicious way to combine two classic holiday flavors.

Set up a holiday drink station

Hosting Christmas dinner or a holiday party?

Make a batch of eggnog ahead of time and keep it chilled.

Set out glasses, cinnamon sticks, nutmeg, and whipped cream so guests can customize their drinks.

You could even offer a few other family-friendly favorites, like Homemade Hot Mulled Cider or 3-Ingredient Grinch Punch.

How to Store Homemade Eggnog

Since this recipe contains eggs and dairy, proper storage is important.

And because it’s a family-friendly recipe, I want to make sure everyone can enjoy it safely!

How long does homemade eggnog last?

Store your homemade eggnog in a covered, airtight container in the refrigerator at 40°F or below.

For best food safety, use it within 2–3 days.

Although some recipes suggest longer storage times, I prefer the more conservative recommendation for homemade eggnog.

Can I make eggnog ahead of time?

Absolutely!

In fact, I highly recommend it.

Making eggnog the night before gives it time to chill completely and allows the flavors to blend together.

Just keep it refrigerated until you’re ready to serve.

Can I leave homemade eggnog out at a party?

Because eggnog contains eggs and dairy, it shouldn’t sit at room temperature for more than two hours.

If you’re serving it at a holiday gathering, keep the main batch refrigerated and refill smaller serving pitchers as needed.

You can also nest a serving pitcher in ice to help keep it cold.

Can I freeze homemade eggnog?

Freezing isn’t my first choice because the dairy-and-egg mixture may separate or become grainy after thawing.

For the best creamy texture, I’d recommend making a fresh batch and enjoying it within a few days.

To make the best homemade eggnog, grab our recipe on Made in a Pinch. For more delicious recipes and helpful tips, follow us on Pinterest!

Homemade Eggnog FAQs

Do you have questions about making this classic homemade eggnog recipe? Here are some answers to common questions I get from readers to make it easy to prepare delicious eggnog for your next holiday party!

Is homemade eggnog safe for kids?

This recipe is non-alcoholic, and the egg mixture is cooked to 160°F before serving.
That makes it a family-friendly alternative to recipes containing raw eggs or alcohol.
As with any egg-and-dairy recipe, proper cooking, cooling, refrigeration, and handling are important for reducing foodborne illness risks.

Does homemade eggnog contain raw eggs?

This recipe starts with raw eggs, but they’re cooked as part of the preparation.
The mixture is heated to 160°F before the cream, vanilla, and salt are added.
Some traditional eggnog recipes use uncooked eggs. If you choose one of those recipes, use pasteurized eggs or egg products intended for uncooked preparations.

What temperature should homemade eggnog reach?

Heat the egg mixture to 160°F using a food thermometer.
This is an important food-safety step when preparing homemade eggnog with eggs.
Avoid boiling the mixture because excessive heat can cause the eggs to curdle.

Why does my eggnog taste like custard?

Eggnog and custard share several ingredients, including eggs, milk, sugar, and vanilla.
So a custard-like flavor is perfectly normal!
The cinnamon and nutmeg are what give eggnog its distinctive holiday flavor.
If you prefer a stronger spice flavor, adjust those seasonings slightly to taste.

How do you thicken homemade eggnog?

The eggs naturally thicken the mixture as it cooks and cools.
For the best results, follow the recipe and allow the eggnog to chill completely.
If it’s still thinner than you’d prefer, avoid trying to fix it by overheating it. You can enjoy it as a lighter eggnog rather than risk scrambling the eggs.

Can I use egg yolks instead of whole eggs?

Some eggnog recipes use only egg yolks, but this particular recipe was developed using 12 whole eggs.
Replacing them with yolks would change the richness and texture, and the quantities would need to be adjusted.
For reliable results, I recommend following the recipe as written.

Can I make this eggnog without alcohol?

YES!
In fact, this recipe is completely non-alcoholic as written.
That’s one of the reasons I love making it for my family.
You get all the rich, creamy, traditional eggnog flavor without adding any booze.

Why did my homemade eggnog separate in the refrigerator?

A little separation can happen with homemade eggnog.
Simply stir or whisk it before serving.
If needed, use an immersion blender briefly to bring the mixture back together.

How long should homemade eggnog chill?

I recommend chilling it for at least 5–6 hours, or overnight if possible.
The flavor improves as the spices have time to blend together, and the texture becomes thicker and creamier.
And YES, waiting can be the hardest part!

More Delicious Christmas Drinks and Treats

If you’re planning your holiday menu, don’t stop with the eggnog!

Here are a few more Made in a Pinch favorites your family might love:

Final Thoughts on This Easy Homemade Eggnog Recipe

If you’ve only ever had eggnog from a carton, I hope you’ll give this homemade version a try.

It’s thick, creamy, full of cozy Christmas spices, and made with ingredients you can easily find at the grocery store.

And once you learn the trick to gently cooking the eggs without scrambling them, making homemade eggnog becomes a holiday tradition worth repeating.

I love that this recipe is something the whole family can enjoy, whether we’re decorating the Christmas tree, watching our favorite holiday movies, or gathering around the table with friends.

So grab your whisk, turn on some Christmas music, and get ready to make the BEST homemade eggnog!

Just be prepared.

Once your family tastes it, they might never let you buy another carton again. 😉

Merry Christmas, and happy eggnog making!

Pin For Later!

To make the best homemade eggnog, grab our recipe on Made in a Pinch. For more delicious recipes and helpful tips, follow us on Pinterest!

Homemade Non-Alcoholic Eggnog Recipe

5 from 1 vote
Eggs, cream, and spices combine to create this decadent, smooth, yet creamy homemade non-alcoholic eggnog. Enjoy a batch (or many) this holiday season!
Prep Time 5 minutes
Cook Time 25 minutes
Total Time 6 hours 30 minutes
Servings: 12 servings

Ingredients
  

  • 12 eggs
  • 1 1/4 cup sugar
  • 4 cup whole milk
  • 1 tsp ground nutmeg
  • 1 tsp ground cinnamon
  • 2 tsp vanilla extract
  • 1 cup heavy whipping cream
  • pinch of salt
  • dash of cinnamon for topping

Method
 

  1. Combine the eggs and sugar in a mixing bowl and whisk until thoroughly combined.
  2. Transfer to a saucepan and stir in the whole milk, ground cinnamon, and ground nutmeg.
  3. Heat over medium-low heat, stirring regularly with a whisk and continuously as the mixture gets hot. Heat gently until the mixture reaches 160°F on a food thermometer. Do not boil.
  4. Remove from the heat and slowly whisk in the heavy whipping cream, salt, and vanilla extract.
  5. Allow to cool slightly before tasting. Adjust the sugar or spices if desired.
  6. Cool promptly and transfer to a covered container. Refrigerate within two hours of cooking.
  7. Chill for approximately 5–6 hours or overnight. The eggnog will continue to thicken as it cools.
  8. Stir before serving. Pour into glasses or mugs and garnish with whipped cream, cinnamon sticks, cinnamon, or nutmeg.

Notes

  • For thinner eggnog: Add extra whole milk, approximately ¼ cup at a time, until you reach your preferred consistency.
  • For smoother eggnog: Heat gently, use a whisk, and monitor the temperature carefully. If small cooked-egg lumps develop, try straining the mixture through a fine-mesh strainer.
  • For separated eggnog: Whisk before serving or briefly blend with an immersion blender.
  • For an adults-only version: Add rum, brandy, bourbon, or whiskey to individual adult servings, to taste.
  • Storage: Keep refrigerated at 40°F or below and use within 2–3 days.
  • Food safety: Cook the egg mixture to 160°F and refrigerate promptly. Do not rely on alcohol to make raw eggs safe.

Tried this recipe?

Let us know how it was!

Similar Posts

67 Comments

  1. 5 stars
    I’ve been making this recipe for about 6 years at Christmas. I follow the recipe exactly. 1 year i had lumps, but only because I rushed it. We do add rum! Thanks!

    1. Hi Shelby! Thanks for letting me know! It’s a delicious recipe – but you’re right…it does take a little time and isn’t one you can rush! Thanks for trying it again after you had lumps, and I’m thrilled that you make it each year!

    1. Hi Christie! I’m so glad you didn’t get lumps! I think eggnog in general does have a little bit of a custard flavor. Part of what gives eggnog its distinctive flavor is the nutmeg and cinnamon. Did you add those spices in the amounts listed in the recipe?

  2. I’m so sad! I stirred for an hour and it still came out with tiny lumps! What an expensive mistake. We can’t get eggnog here for love nor money so I thought I’d try my own, never again…….

    1. Hi Becky! I’m so sorry to hear that! I’ve made this recipe dozens of time and the only times I’ve ever gotten lumps (only 2-3 times) was when I had the heat too high or I got distracted (even for just a couple of minutes). Some things that help me not get lumps are to stir with a wisk instead of a spoon and delegate other tasks to other people so you aren’t distracted.

      Also, if you do end up with lumps, you can still save your eggnog! Just take a fine strainer and strain the liquid through it. It will pull our the lumps and leave you with creamy eggnog!

    1. Hi Lori! No, you can’t let them go to waste! Here’s what I would do to fix it.

      1) I would try reheating it and using a whisk to get the lumps out. You could also use a spoon and basically “smash” the lumps against the side of the pan, but if they’re small you won’t be able to get them. A whisk can often break lumps apart as you stir.

      To thin it out, simply add a little more whole milk as you stir.

      Heating, using a whisk, and thinning it out may solve your problem. If it doesn’t, do this:

      2) Pour your eggnog through a strainer into a bowl, etc. The strainer will catch the lumps and let the best part pass through.

      I hope this helps!

    1. Hey Brittany! I would say 3-4 days is safe. Possibly up to 7 days, although you’re likely to have lots of separation at that point (but it shouldn’t spoiled).

  3. HI Heather, I’m planning to make your recipe this evening. Do you think using a double boiler would help keep it from scorching or getting lumpy?

    1. Hi Dana! I think if you feel the most comfortable with that (and realize going into it that a double boiler will take more time), then go for it. It can’t hurt!

  4. Could you do this in a high power blender instead of on the stove top? Since they heat up while they blend, I’m wondering if it would achieve the same results.

    1. Hey Amber! I really don’t know the answer to that. My first thought would be no – unless you are planning to add alcohol. If you want this eggnog to be non-alcoholic, it really needs to heat up to 160 degrees which is the safe temperature for eggs to prevent salmonella poisoning. I don’t think a high power blender would get it that hot, but I could definitely be wrong about that (clearly I don’t have one!).

        1. That’s so cool, Tina! Please come back and let me know how it worked out – I’d be happy to add it to the post as a note if it works well for you!

  5. After reading the comments I was so paranoid that my eggs would scramble, so I diligently stirred the mix with a whisk.. well, a word from the now wise, don’t mix this too much. I think I stirred it so much that it took FOREVER to reach 160 degrees. Like, an hour. Not very helpful I know.. mix it a lot, it not too much 🥴

    1. Hey Monica! LOL, it can be hard to find that balance! Your arm must have been tired! So sorry it took you so long! Maybe a compromise would be don’t stir much AT FIRST. Then as it starts to warm up, begin stirring regularly – even if it’s just a good swirl, pause, swirl. The basic goal is that you don’t want the milk mixture sitting still or it will scorch and your eggs will scramble. A pause is fine (it’s what I do), but some people interpret “pause” as not a 3-5 second break but rather a “go switch out the laundry” kind of a break which will ruin your eggnog.

    2. You can buy an electric silicone stir bot on Amazon for less than $20. It vibrates and swivels around the pot so you don’t have to do a thing. It takes a while to cook but I can set up my thermometer and leave the kitchen to do other things and not worry about the nog. I even use my man’s meat thermometer that beeps when it reaches 160. It’s literally the easiest thing to make ever like this and so yummy! Hope this helps!

      I seriously make this every single Christmas, and for our Christmas in July. It’s perfect without the alcohol but my favorite addition is to add TX whiskey for the ones that want it spiked.

        1. Hi Catryna! I have added a few links to stirrers in the post to try to help with this. I don’t recommend the electric stir bot but there are other great options.

    1. Hi Rebecca! I’ve never made half as I’ve always made it for more people. However, I don’t see why you can’t, and as we’re not celebrating with family this year, I’ll be trying it myself!

    2. You want every drop of this yummy drink. Do yourself a favor, make the whole recipe. It won’t last long.

  6. Hi Heather,
    So i just made your eggnog and it is really delicious!! I had never tried it in my life! If I may be so bold I would like to give you some advice, from one chef to another 😉 if you first cook the milk with the spices (i also used whole vanilla) then slowly pour it on to the eggs-sugar en then put it back in the saucepan until 160 following recipe its easier and safer for the eggs not to scrabble.
    Kind regards Chaveli

    1. Hi Chaveli! Thanks for the suggestion. I’ll add it to the tips. When using this method the eggs definitely need to be tempered so they don’t scramble, which in testing we had more trouble with. However, for some people, it might work better, so I’ll add it. Thanks!

    2. I really wish I read this before I tried it. I did everything as described, continuously stirring, had the thermometer in, never left it for a second and took it off heat as soon as it hit 160 and it’s all chunky. 🙁 I think it might be best to have done this from the start. I have strained it and there are still chunks forming while it cools 🙁

        1. Hey Christy! I’m sorry you ended up with chunky eggnog! Definitely NOT the texture you want, right?! What if you try stirring with a whisk as your eggnog heats up? That’s what I do and it might help prevent chunks as they start to form. I’ll update the recipe to make sure it says that clearly.

  7. Soooo I’m pregnant in the middle of summer and have been wanting eggnog since early on. Finally got to make this and it has hit the spot! So much better than store bought! I added a dash of cloves for an extra spice kick. Will be making this again for Christmas. Baby girl will be here by then.

  8. Made this for Christmas and served the whiskey on the side. SO good!! SO much better than store bought. Would highly recommend this recipe! I even left out the nutmeg bc the store was out. But I’m sure it’s be even better with but we didn’t even miss it!

    1. Hi Lisa! I’m so glad you enjoyed the eggnog! The nutmeg does add a whole different level of depth to the flavor – if you make it again, try adding the nutmeg (plus I’m biased because I LOVE nutmeg)!!

    1. Hi Liz, Yes, I would think you could if you prefer it warm. As it cools, it thickens and the flavors “marry” more. But if you want to go ahead and drink it, go for it!

  9. Hi there,
    I followed your recipe and made sure to stir constantly while over medium low heat. I even used a thermometer the whole time and took it right off when it reached the temp you suggested. It has all these chunks in it even still. I tried straining them out the best I could because it’s a lot of eggs, milk etc to waste! 🙁 I’m so disappointed!
    Don’t you think it’d be better to try this over a double boiler or something?

    1. Hey Kelsey, I’m so sorry you had trouble with the recipe! Thanks for coming back to let me know. It sounds like your stove was either too hot or you briefly stopped stirring. The temp and constant stirring are the most important elements with this because milk can scorch so quickly and eggs can scramble.

      I know sometimes people will try to speed recipes like this up but turning the stove on higher heat until it gets warm, but that’s a recipe for disaster with this recipe. You could try a double boiler – maybe for your stove that would be a better fit, but I’ve never had trouble with the recipe or tried a double boiler with it.

  10. I Love this recipe. This is the 2nd time I made homemade eggnog. The first recipe I used did not turn out well. This recipe how ever was simple and just down right awesome. I doubled the batch for a family gathering and it was a hit. Even those who say they don’t like eggnog, loved it. You just can’t compare store bought eggnog and the homemade version., they aren’t remotely the same taste. I gave everyone the option of adding rum to their individual cups rather than spiking the whole batch. I may tweak the sugar just a bit. It was on the sweet side but overall this recipe is a keeper.

    1. Hi Amy! I am so happy to hear this and am totally stoked that your family loved it too! I do have a bit of a sweet tooth, but that’s the beauty of making it yourself – you can tailor it to your preference!!! Thanks for letting me know how it turned out, Amy!

  11. Hello there! I can’t wait to try out the recipe. …. since I live on Germany and it’s not sold at the grocery stores out here I have to give it a shot. Wish me luck! One question though. The recipe ask’s for heavy whipping cream. Just the liquid or does it have to be whipped before I put it in the saucepan?
    Thank you in advance,
    Anja

    1. Hi Anja! Yay! I’m so excited for you to try it! No need to whip the heavy whipping cream prior to adding it to the saucepan. Once you add it to the saucepan, you’ll be whisking it then to keep it from scorching. Good luck but I’m sure you don’t need it 🙂

      1. I had my students make this yesterday so they could drink it today and it was so slimey from the egg whites. It’s that normal?

        1. Hey Ana! Oh no, how disappointing! Honestly, I’m not sure why it would be slimy. I’ve never had that happen. Did you use whole eggs (instead of just egg whites) and cook them to 160 degrees? My first thought is that the eggnog didn’t get hot enough when cooking, you only used egg whites, or that it cooled too quickly?

          I even researched it and couldn’t find a reason for slimy cooked eggnog. I’m sorry – I just don’t know, but I will keep searching to see if I can find out.

    1. Hi Kelli! I would say 7 days is safe. You *might* be able to keep it a day or two longer, but if you try to do that, be sure to check that it hasn’t spoiled before you drink it!

  12. The only eggnog I’ll ever make. I made this for my husband because he loves eggnog but I don’t. Turns out I just loathe store bought egg nog. I found this recipe to be delicious.

  13. I just made this. Yummmmmm. I have always purchased eggnog. However,I always thought that the store bought versions were too sweet. Making this was sooooo easy. I could also adjust the sugar content to my taste. I would suggest freshly ground nutmeg for the best flavor.

    1. Hey! Yay!! I am SO HAPPY to hear that you love the recipe! I also completely agree about adjusting the sugar content – that’s what I LOVE about making things from scratch. I can make them exactly the way I like them (and feel better about knowing what the ingredients are). Good point about the freshly ground nutmeg – you’re right, that would be an even better flavor!

    1. Hey Angie! Honestly, I’ve never tried making it with almond milk. I think it could be really good with almond milk. The thing to keep in mind, though is that almond milk has way less fat and creaminess than whole milk. I suggest giving it a try. If it’s not as thick or creamy as you would prefer, consider using coconut milk instead. It has a higher fat content/creaminess that could substitute well if you don’t mind the flavor.

      1. Hey Heather! So glad it tasted great! What if you tried adding another egg or two or cooking it down just a little longer to let it thicken a little more?

  14. Hi!
    So I have a couple of questions.
    1.) Is it supposed to separate?? I checked on it about 2 hrs after putting it in the fridge & it had separated.
    2.) Is it supposed to be super smooth? Because mine isn’t…

    1. Hey Storm! Good questions!
      1. Yes, it CAN separate. Just throw it in the blender before serving for a quick pulse to mix it all up OR use an immersion blender to combine everything before serving if it separates.
      2. It should be smooth. Without knowing more, what might have happened was that either the milk scorched or the eggs scrambled a bit. When heating the mixture, it’s crucial to stir constantly so that both of those things don’t happen. It’s also easy to forget or get busy doing something else while you’re waiting for it to heat up 🙂

      I love the questions! I’ll update the recipe to include this info so others be sure to see it too.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.